Photo: Byredo

Makeup

Colored Mascaras That Will Add Depth To Your Eyes

This fall, it’s time for colored mascaras to have a permanent seat at the makeup table.

Text Başak Ulubilgen

September 22, 2023

Colored mascaras are underrated. They bring an effortless change to your look enough for people to realize something is delightfully different but subtle enough that they can’t really tell what. I remember the very first time I used a tawny, brownish mascara. It provided a sparkle to my hazel eyes that black ones never did. Don’t get me wrong. Black is classic for a reason; it’s universal. But the best thing about these mascaras is that you can use one that has the ability to enhance your eye color. If you’re skeptical about colored mascaras, start with something muted like brown or deep plum. Once you get the hang of it, you will realize that they will add depth and dimension to your eyes, especially when paired with suitable eyeshadows. We made a list of our favorite black-alternative mascaras that can bring a fresh change to your fall makeup routine. Take your pick below!

Byredo Mascara in Mixed Emotions, $46

Another unique burgundy-colored mascara is this limited-edition one from Byredo, one of Valerie’s recent favorites in her everyday makeup routine. It has a vegan formula and a curvy brush to help lift the lashes and hold their curl. You can use this one for a softer look to make your brown-adjacent eyes pop.

Chanel Le Volume de Chanel Mascara in Blue Night, $38

This buildable mascara from Chanel is all about the volume granted by the natural waxes in the formula. The fast-drying agent, acacia gum, helps set the curl. This particular shade of navy blue can go with any colored eyes but for different effects. For example, brown or hazel-eyed folk can use it for contrast. In the meantime, this color will help enhance blue or green eyes.

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara in Dream Pop, $29

Here’s a universally flattering berry-brown shade from makeup legend Charlotte Tilbury. Taking a prominent spot in the brand’s iconic Pillow Talk collection, this mascara has a water-resistant formula that conditions the lashes with keratin. Its diamond-shaped bristles make it easy to fan out the lashes.

Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara in Dark Green, $32

Meet Dior’s first refillable mascara. It contains cornflower floral water, which is known to have soothing properties. This could be a good option for those with sensitive eyes and skin. Its spoon-like brush tip with a long-lasting formula helps fan out and lift the lashes (and keeps them that way). Green, hazel, and brown eyes will benefit most from this dark green hue.

Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse Serum-Infused Mascara in Noir Malachite, $33

Lancôme, perhaps the godmother of mascaras, recently came out with this two-in-one option. The serum-infused, easy-to-remove formula contains 91% black balm, eight types of amino acids, and shea butter for a conditioned set of lashes. The hourglass-shaped vegetal brush helps add volume. The emerald green tone complements dark eyes.

Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Volume Effet Faux Cils in Bourgogne, $29

Even though this mascara has been around for years, it now comes in a new formula enriched with B5 pro-vitamin to condition the lashes. This deep burgundy color goes well with all eye colors: Brown, hazel, green, and blue. It has a nylon fiber brush that makes it easier to build and control how statement-y you want your eyes to look.

 PreviousNext  

 

Related Stories